http://www.irishecho.com/newspaper/story.cfm?id=19375
One Ireland
Federal Ireland idea aired at NY forum
By Ray O'Hanlon
In the first of what will be a series of gatherings in the U.S. and other countries where there is a strong Irish diaspora, the path and the process by which Ireland will be reunited was the centerpiece of a forum in New York City last weekend organized by Sinn Féin.
The forum, under the banner of "Unite Ireland," and held at the Hilton Hotel in Manhattan, was attended by over 700 delegates and activists from around the U.S. and addressed by a panel of invited speakers as well as others representing an array of Irish American organizations.
There were also representatives of both the Irish and British governments at the gathering.
The forum was intended as an open debate and the audience was treated to a broad assessment of how Irish unity will be ultimately achieved - more than one speaker stressed that it was a matter of when, not if - and indeed what a unified Ireland might ultimately look like.
One scenario, outlined by Professor Brendan O'Leary of the University of Pennsylvania, was a possible federation of the present northern six counties and he southern 26.
And in what for many in the room was the emotional heart of the day's discussions, former Beirut hostage Brian Keenan, a Belfast Protestant by birth, delivered his view of the nature of the division on the island and his hopes for its ending in a series of stories that transfixed his audience.
The forum was opened by Friends of Sinn Féin president Larry Downes and party leader Gerry Adams who, in speaking to the press beforehand and the audience minutes later, said that the question for the Irish diaspora and Irish America was not how to get to a united Ireland, but how they could help achieve what was inevitable.
A united Ireland, said Adams, was not a matter of if, but of how and when. The forum, he said, was the beginning of a new phase of action and activism in the United States, one that would take on much of the appearance of the MacBride Principles campaign that garnered widespread community and political support behind the effort to secure fair employment in Northern Ireland.
Adams said it was important to discuss what kind of a united Ireland would take shape. The process, he said, was more than just a changing of flags.
The business of uniting orange and green would be done in Ireland, he said. The mechanism for doing this was contained in the Good Friday Agreement.
Adams asserted that partition had lost its influence as a result of economic progress on an island where "business unionism" now broadly shared the view of an all island economy.
And unionism, Adams emphasized, would have to play a central part in the gaining of unity.
He said it would require "huge outreach to our unionist brothers and sisters."
Adams opined that the economic and political dynamics in Ireland were combining to make unity possible "in a reasonable time." While stating his view that "this generation" could make full Irish freedom a reality, Adams emphasized that a lot of work would still be required.
"Doing," he said, "is the difference between dreaming and success."
The unity of Ireland, Adams said, was bigger than Sinn Féin, which did not have a monopoly on what was a "primary national and international issue."
With this in mind, he said there was the potential to mobilize the diaspora in a way never seen before.
Author and journalist Pete Hamill provided the introductions for the main invited speakers. The son of immigrants form Belfast, Hamill noted that the "icepack" that had been the core of political division in Ireland was now breaking up.
Professor Brendan O'Leary of the University of Pennsylvania said that the issue of unity would require extensive public debate and analysis that would take a long time.
But the process, he said, was an "honorable" one for which there was "no violent road." O'Leary spoke of the much vaunted demography of the North and played up the potential importance of immigration there, especially by "Polish Catholics with UK passports."
He did not think that, as per some predictions, there would be a nationalist majority by 2023 and he was of the view that the gains by nationalists in the overall population of the North had likely flattened out.
There was, he said, "no quick victory" for Irish nationalism "through the cradle."
As such, a "substantial portion of unionists and Protestants" needed to be converted to the idea of a united Ireland. In this regard the growing secularism on the island in general was diminishing old arguments against unity such as the "Rome rule" one.
Rome rule, he quipped, was no longer the rule of the Vatican but "the Rome of the pagans."
O'Leary introduced something that perhaps many at the forum were thinking about in the backs of their minds rather than in their foremost thoughts and that was federalism. There were, he said "practical and principled" reasons to advocate a federal Ireland.
O'Leary argued that the "population explosion" in the South stood to give the North much less clout in a united Ireland than once would have been the case.
A federal Ireland, he said, would dilute this effect. Such a federation would not necessarily be based on the historical four provinces but a two unit federation between the existing six county North and the South which, he said, could break into smaller units if it so desired.
There would be a need to persuade others such as immigrant groups in the North in order to establish a required backdrop for unity of peace and pluralism, said O'Leary.
The arrival of those groups made a federal Ireland more possible.
O'Leary focused on the difficulties of winning over public opinion in the South to the idea of unity.
"There had been "estrangement" over the 90 years of partition and a fear in the South over potential violence from northern Protestants.
Consent for unity on the southern side, he said, would minimally require the cooperation of the SDLP in the North, Fianna Fáil, Labour and the Greens in the South.
Fine Gael's name in English, he reminded listeners, was also the Irish unity party.
In addition to the listed speakers, the forum was also addressed by Senator Charles Schumer and Congressman Eliot Engel.
Schumer drew a comparison between New York and its 62 counties, America and its 50 states, and Ireland and its 32 counties.
Schumer said that with regards to Ireland he looked forward to "one great united country in our lifetimes."
Brendan Keenan provided the emotional touchstone on the day in a delivery that kept all in the room riveted. The man who spent over four years as a hostage in Beirut was joined in the room by fellow former hostage Terry Anderson.
Both men were cheered and applauded loudly. Keenan's account of growing up in a part of East Belfast where "the men ate ball bearings for breakfast" was especially notable by virtue of his telling of how the lone Catholic family on his street had fared during his boyhood.
While this family lived only feet away from Protestant neighbors, they were separated from their neighbors, and their neighbors were separated from them, by an "ocean of misunderstanding."
Keenan remembered Bloody Sunday as a catharsis that left him thinking that there "had to be another Ireland, bigger and better than this."
Keenan said that if there was to be a united republic it would have to be one of the heart and mind and with the capacity to look outside itself.
"The way there begins today by talking and listening," he said.
Labor leader Terry O'Sullivan wrapped up the listed speakers with a rousing call to action during which he praised Gerry Adams as "an Irish hero, an American hero, and a world hero." "
A lot of people," he said, "gave their lives for us to be here in this room talking about a united Ireland," said O'Sullivan who said that organized labor had "thousands" of organizers and "boots on the street" that could be utilized in the campaign for Irish unity.
"We stand for a united Ireland once and for all," he said.
Following the platform speakers a long line of individuals who had signed up to make short statements to the audience did so in what was a second half of the three-hour long forum.
First up was Ancient Order of Hibernians National President Seamus Boyle who said that an Ireland united and free was the top priority for the Hibernians.
And the AOH, he said, vowed to be a "major player" in the campaign to secure unity.
Boyle said the Hibernians would be making a special effort to "revitalize" the congressional Ad Hoc Committee for Irish Affairs and the Friends of Ireland in Congress.
Joe McManus, president of the United Irish Counties, said that in his organization's mindset, Ireland was already united.
Kate McCabe of the Irish American Unity Conference chose human rights as the primary focus for her brief address while Gerry Coleman, Kate Murphy and Dan O'Rourke of Irish Northern aid pledged an all out effort.
O'Rourke said the MacBride Principles campaign should serve as a model for the united Ireland effort.
Also addressing the audience were Joe Jamison of the Irish American Labor Coalition, Marty Cottingham of the Irish American Republicans, Danny Brown of Clan na Gael.
Rep. Engel, speaking at this juncture, noted that in Barack Obama, the U.S. had a president who "understands Irish freedom."
"We will continue to talk to him," Engel vowed.
Borrowing a line made famous by his adopted land, Fr. Sean McManus spoke of Ireland being "one nation under God." McManus stressed the importance of battling sectarianism even as the effort to secure unity gathered momentum.
Publisher Niall O'Dowd focused on the importance of educating Catholics and Protestants in the same schools in Northern Ireland, this as a way of breaking down social barriers.
Denise Doyle of the Philadelphia Irish Society and Sean Riordan of the Brehon Law Society, activist Jack Kilroy from Cleveland, Ted Sullivan from Atlanta, Ed Shevlin of the Grand Council of Emerald Societies, Ciaran Staunton of the Irish Lobby for Immigration Reform, and Steve McCabe of the Irish Reconciliation Committee - which has made groundbreaking contacts with loyalist paramilitary groups - were just some of the speakers who focused on different aspects that will emerge as a united Ireland campaign progresses.
In concluding the forum, Gerry Adams described the gathering as the commencement of a new phase.
"We cannot contemplate failure, or go out of here and falter. It's too important," he said.
"We have the ability, the capability, the potential to be the generation that brings about Irish unity.
"The Irish government has a constitutional imperative to bring about Irish unity. Irish America should remind them of that. Let's go from here and do the work," he said.
The forum is being reconvened in San Francisco on Saturday, June 27.
This story appeared in the issue of June 17-23, 2009