http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/opinion/mccord-testimony-wonrsquot-be-the-last-on-capitol-hill-14541552.html
When Raymond McCord appeared before a US House of Representatives sub-committee yesterday he became the latest of many Northern Ireland people whose Capitol Hill testimony has highlighted the reach and the limits of Congressional influence in the province’s affairs.
Although members like the late Senator Edward Kennedy were initially critical of Britain through the years, most Capitol Hill pronouncements have tended toward moderation.
Ironically, the Congress member who first took the most active interest in the conflict was New York’s Mario Biaggi — an Italian-American whose constituency was light of Irish-American voters.
As the story goes, Biaggi’s long-held casual interest hit overdrive in the aftermath of Bloody Sunday when his daughter travelled to Londonderry to probe on-the-ground |realities after the killings.
By 1977, Biaggi had set up the Ad Hoc Committee on Irish Affairs in the US House of Representatives and he began pushing for official Congressional hearings into allegations that RUC interrogators were torturing IRA suspects. Two years later, on the basis of those allegations, Congressman Biaggi was instrumental in getting the US State Department to place embargo on US small arms supplies to the RUC.
However, Biaggi’s quest for a full Congressional probe into alleged human rights abuses committed by the security forces was thwarted by the legendary Speaker of the House Tip O’Neil.
O’Neil, a Massachusetts Democrat, had been told by Irish government officials in Washington that such a hearing would be a huge propaganda coup for the IRA, so he steadfastly blocked Biaggi’s efforts for the remainder of the 1980s.
Fast-forward to the early 1990s and, with the peace process gathering steam, Capitol Hill’s interest grew accordingly — particularly after the IRA and loyalist ceasefires of 1994 and the forging of the Good Friday Agreement.
Activists who’d tried for decades to peak Congressional interest in issues such as collusion or human rights abuses found more on Capitol Hill willing to act.
For example, in 1999, Congress passed legislation requiring RUC members that were due to participate in FBI training exercises to be screened for past human rights abuses in Northern Ireland (a requirement later lifted by George W Bush in 2001).
During the past decade there have been several Congressional hearings on the peace process, human rights, and collusion. During once proceeding — held six months before she was killed in a car-bombing — Lurgan solicitor Rosemary Nelson testified that RUC members had made death-threats against her.
Irish republicans have also endured Congressional scrutiny.
In 2002, Illinois Republican congressman Henry Hyde held hearings into the case of the Colombia Three — a year after they were arrested leaving a FARC-controlled area of the South American country.
But does Congressional attention really provide any advantage to campaigners in Northern Ireland?
On one hand, London has never scurried to react to US Congressional queries they haven’t agreed with. It’s been nearly three years since the House of Representatives passed a resolution calling for a fully independent judicial inquiry into the murder of Pat Finucane, yet Britain hasn’t yet budged.
On the other hand, in light of the involvement of presidents Bill Clinton and George Bush and even Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s recent trip, London can’t risk ignoring official input from Congress.
As revelations about the activities of the Mount Vernon UVF — and their responsibility for murdering Mr McCord’s son, Raymond Jnr — have shown, the dark corners of Northern Ireland’s dirty war are far from hidden any more.
As things move towards the possible creation of some sort of comprehensive truth-finding process in Northern Ireland, it’s very likely that future Congressional inquiries and hearings will play a role in that process.
And Raymond McCord’s testimony is the latest, but not likely the last, proof of that reality.
http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/weekend/2009/1024/1224257361514.html
The refurbished Ulster Museum’s planned Troubles exhibition is much smaller than expected. Is it a case of ‘don’t mention the war’?
The Ulster Museum, which has reopened after a £17 million refit of the interior exhibition spaces. Photograph: Kelvin Boyes/presseye.com/PA Wire
THIS WEEK, the Ulster Museum – known locally as “the culture bunker”, because of its brooding Brutalist concrete exterior – reopened after a £17 million refurbishment. The iconic building appears to have undergone a glossy television-style makeover: the dark warren of the original galleries has been replaced with open spaces, unadorned white walls, glass walkways and polished steel. There’s a distinct emphasis on instant visual impact – “Window on our World”, a four-storey display tower, aims to provide a snapshot of the collections, with dinosaur skeletons, a vintage car and an Irish high cross. And the new interactive zones allow visitors to handle the skull of a two-headed calf, or try on Victorian corsets and crinolines.
But the pizzazz of the revamp does not seem to have extended as far as the new Troubles gallery.
Tucked away in a gloomy corner, it combines panels of dense factual text with black and white photographs documenting the conflict. No artefacts or relics of the conflict are on display: there are pictures of guns, for example, but no real guns; a single reproduction of a republican “comm”, or prison letter, but no sign of the letter itself. As one visitor remarked: “it’s a cop-out – a definite case of ‘don’t mention the war’”.
A bland, safe and strenuously non-controversial Troubles exhibition was not the original idea for Northern Ireland’s first permanent gallery dedicated to the 1968-98 conflict. There were plans to exhibit bullet-riddled boots and the shirt worn by SDLP founding leader, the late Gerry Fitt, when he was bludgeoned with a police baton at a civil rights rally, as well as paintings such as Ulster Crucifixion – a multi-panel altarpiece by Troubles artist Ken Howard.
“The new Troubles gallery is tentative,” admits Tim Cooke, director of National Museums Northern Ireland. “We are trying to give a headline sense of the key issues here. But you can’t resolve this stuff. People might expect a definitive exhibition. The impact of the Troubles is unresolved – so the gallery is unresolved.”
The Ulster Museum has always prided itself on its collections of contemporary material – the institution’s copy of the 1916 Proclamation was acquired in April 1916, and it holds items such as Mairéad Corrigan’s 1976 Nobel Peace Medal and the 1974 2nd Battalion IRA Roll of Honour from Long Kesh. In fact, many of these Troubles artefacts have already been on display in the museum in the recent past. In Conflict: the Irish at War, an exhibition that ran from 2003 until the museum’s closure for renovation in 2006, British Army bullets and an RUC helmet and shield damaged during the street fighting in Derry in 1969 were shown. An official evaluation showed that the majority of visitors who came to see that exhibition did so because they valued the courage the museum demonstrated in curating an exhibition on this sensitive topic. It was judged “Best Exhibition 2004” at the Museum of the Year Award.
But there have been damaging controversies too: in 1978, attendants at the museum refused to hang Silver Liberties: A Souvenir of a Wonderful Anniversary Year , Conrad Atkinson’s artwork commemorating Bloody Sunday. The staff’s “work-to-rule” action was backed by the museum’s trustees, and caused a stand-off with the Northern Ireland Arts Council, which described it as “a denial of creative freedom”. “Silver Liberties” is currently held at the Wolverhampton Art Gallery, which has one of the biggest collections of Troubles art in Ireland and Britain. A group of Belfast artists is campaigning to have the piece reinstated in the new Troubles gallery at the museum.
It’s true that interpreting the past is a risky business, leaving institutions open to charges of political bias, over-simplification or inaccuracy. Then there’s the question of timing. The dust gathered at Kilmainham for 60 years before the jail was developed as a monument to the Civil War.
Is it simply too soon for a full-scale Troubles exhibition? Dr Kris Brown, who compiled an audit of Troubles artefacts for the cross-community organisation Healing Through Remembering, says he can imagine what that exhibition would look like. “There is so much material out there, and so many stories and narratives that could be told via artefacts, images and testimony, that with a modicum of focus, funding and collaboration a really innovative and memorable exhibition or museum could be created. It would do justice to people’s memories as well as challenging some of the encrusted positions of a divided society.”
Dr Brown says it’s important to be sensitive – but not to play for safety. “What we shouldn’t do is forget about it, or just indulge in two-dimensional Troubles nostalgia . . . Can one local institution deliver a world-class exhibition on division and political violence? Perhaps not, but we should start planning how we could.”
http://www.herald.ie/national-news/until-now-the-last-time-sinn-fein-met-a-tory-leader-it-was-1921-and-collins-was-negotiating-the-treaty-1922936.html
By David Sharrock
Friday October 23 2009
David Cameron has become the first British Tory party leader since partition to meet Sinn Fein.
The historic meeting took place with the North's Deputy First Minister and former IRA chief of staff Martin McGuinness.
First Minister Peter Robinson and McGuinness had signed off on a £1bn financial agreement to fund the transfer of policing and justice powers to Stormont.
British prime minister Gordon Brown called it the "final piece in the jigsaw of the peace process".
With a general election in Britain next year, the North's politicians wanted assurances from Mr Cameron that he would honour the pledge if voted into government.
As a result of that request, Mr Cameron became the first leader of his party to meet a Sinn Fein leader since 1921 when Austen Chamberlain was a member of David Lloyd George's team negotiating the Treaty with Michael Collins and a Sinn Fein delegation.
Those meetings led to partition and decades of conflict that still persist, albeit on a lesser scale since the 1998 Good Friday agreement.
John Major, the last British Conservative prime minister, said in 1993 that it would turn his stomach to negotiate with the Provisional IRA, even though that was what he had authorised in secret.
William Whitelaw was the last senior Conservative to meet IRA leaders, playing host to Gerry Adams at secret talks in London in 1972.
Mr McGuinness said after meeting Mr Cameron: "I am very happy to report that he is very supportive of the immediate transfer of powers on policing and justice and that he will respect the agreement."
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton used a visit to the North earlier this month to urge rival leaders to cooperate over taking control of law and order.
She said taking control of justice duties would be the most effective deterrent to the "thuggish tactics and destructive ambitions" of dissident IRA members.
"The generous financial package for devolved policing and justice is a major step forward," said Foreign Affairs Minister Micheal Martin.
hnews@herald.