http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/breaking/2009/0225/breaking50.htm
Wed, Feb 25, 2009
A controversial proposal to pay £12,000 to the families of all those died in the Troubles - including the families of paramilitaries - will not be implemented, the British government has announced.
The recognition payment was one of 31 recommendations made by a group commissioned to investigate ways of dealing with the legacy of the past.
Northern Ireland secretary of state Shaun Woodward said although there were many workable elements of the Eames/Bradley report, he ruled out the introduction of the payment scheme.
The contentious suggestion prompted angry protests from families of those killed by terrorists. Mr Woodward said the proposal could not be introduced given the lack of consensus on the issue.
“The only way to go forward with this is if we can establish consensus on it,” he said.
"It is my view having studied this very carefully that very clearly there is huge disagreement about this particular proposal. I therefore think it would be helpful to make it clear that the government’s response to Eames/Bradley report will not include accepting that recommendation.”
The Secretary of State clarified the British government’s position ahead of an appearance by the report’s authors, former Church of Ireland archbishop Robin Eames and former vice-chairman of the Northern Ireland Policing Board Denis Bradley - at a Westminster committee today.
They are to be questioned by the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee, which is carrying out a “short inquiry” into the findings.
The total cost of implementing all the proposals was estimated at about £300 million.
Other recommendations in their report included:
- A five-year Legacy Commission with an international chairman to investigate many of the more than 3,600 killings. In a twin-track approach, it would offer relatives the chance to pursue prosecutions or forgo that to instead seek information on how their loved one died.
- Taking over the work of police units looking into the past would save an estimated £100 million.
- It would work with a Reconciliation Forum to tackle issues such as sectarianism and addiction, with the help of a £100 million bursary.
- It did not propose an amnesty for crimes from the Trouble, but argued a line may be drawn on the past when the five-year Legacy Commission ended.
- Current public inquiries would finish, but no more would be established.
The report also challenged politicians to take a lead role in the future at an annual day of reflection and reconciliation.
Mr Woodward said the report’s author had carried out monumental work and said many of the recommendations had a lot of potential. “There are really interesting ideas and those ideas we would like to look at very carefully,” he said.
Mr Bradley welcomed what he said was Mr Woodward’s broad backing for other aspects of the proposals.
“I am very pleased that we had a very, very positive response from the Secretary of State in that he recognises that this [the report] is the way forward and he is putting his people to work on it and that is a very positive development,” Mr Bradley said.
He said the British government would eventually reconsider the recognition payments plan as a means of recognising the suffering of all those bereaved. “People will come back to it in a few years time,” said Mr Bradley.
“The proposal may be inept . . .
but this is an issue that every conflict in the world has to settle.” He added: “I am very pleased by the Secretary of State’s initial reaction. He has understood the report and the issue.”
Democratic Unionist Party leader Peter Robinson welcomed the decision to drop the £12,000 recognition payment proposal. The DUP leader claimed the payments would have been grossly offensive and entirely inappropriate.
“It would have drawn no distinction whatsoever between murderers and the innocent people murdered during the Troubles,” he said. The DUP made it clear to the Government that this proposal was unacceptable.
“Both the prime minister and the secretary of state were left in no doubt that people in Northern Ireland would never accept this morally offensive idea," he said. “I welcome this sensible decision that the Government will not be proceeding to implement the £12,000 pay-off idea.”
SDLP victims spokeswoman Dolores Kelly called on the British government to ensure that their agencies delivered truth and reconciliation for victims.
“Today’s decision by the secretary of state to rule out a £12,000 payment to all families bereaved as a result of the Troubles was somewhat inevitable,” she said. "The SDLP raised concerns about this proposal from the start and are on the record as saying this particular recommendation needed revisiting.
“However, it is worth remembering that this is only one element of a comprehensive report which contains many worthy issues that merit careful consideration."
Traditional Unionist Voice leader Jim Allister had protested at the Belfast ceremony to launch the Eames/Bradley report.
He said: “The decision by the secretary of state to pull the £12,000 payment is a direct result of pressure from innocent victims.
“Those who made it clear that they would not accept a payment which would imply that they see no difference between those who suffered from terrorism and those who perpetrated it are to be congratulated for their principled stand.
“I deeply regret that the insensitive proposals put forward by Eames/Bradley have opened up old wounds and caused deep hurt among innocent victims.”
Ulster Unionist MEP Jim Nicholson also welcomed Mr Woodward’s decision. “I am delighted that the Secretary of State has let common sense prevail,” he said.
The Commission for Victims and Survivors urged the British Government and the devolved administration in Northern Ireland to give the recommendations of the Consultative Group on the Past full consideration.
Commissioner Patricia MacBride said: “We would hope that the secretary of state has decided to publicly set aside this element of the report at this time in order that the remaining 30 recommendations can be studied in their entirety.
PA
© 2009 irishtimes.com
http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/ireland/2009/0225/1224241774944.html
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
FRANK MILLAR, London EditorTHE “INFORMATION recovery” process envisaged by the Eames Bradley report could hamper reconciliation in Northern Ireland by discarding vital legal protections and procedures enshrined in the common law.
That is the view of Peter Smith QC, who served as a member of the Patten Commission on the reform of the RUC.
He was speaking to The Irish Times as Lord Eames and Denis Bradley – co-chairs of the Consultative Group on the Past – prepared to appear before the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee at Westminster.
While certain to face Unionist and Conservative fire over the proposed “recognition” payments to the families of all “victims” of the Troubles, Lord Eames and Mr Bradley might expect some support from MPs for their efforts to meet parliamentary and public concern by capping the cost of future inquiries into past events.
Mr Smith’s intervention, however, seems certain to augment fears that a “cost driven” process could come at the price of justice for some who are eventually summoned to appear before the proposed Independent Legacy Commission.
The Eames-Bradley report lays stress on the need for its proposals to be “human rights compatible” and recognises that witnesses may need access to legal advice.
Against that, Mr Smith said, the apparent guarantee against self-implication sat alongside a power to compel witnesses and the production of papers, in proceedings intended to be non-adversarial, in which it appeared a person accused of serious wrong-doing or criminality would be denied the basic courtroom rights to face his or her accuser, and to challenge them by means of questioning by their lawyer.
“The position in the common law world is that where serious allegations are to be made, an individual must have these rights,” said Mr Smith.
“For any commission or tribunal to adjudicate on a person’s alleged criminal behaviour without these essential safeguards would be revolutionary.”
Mr Smith said he thought any proposal to permit adverse judgments to be made against individuals by the proposed commission without proper legal challenge “would give rise to grave disquiet” among lawyers and human rights activists generally.
While understanding mounting public concern at the costs generated by the Saville Inquiry into Bloody Sunday, Mr Smith also suggested there was no obvious alternative if individuals were to be properly protected.
“If the courts could protect people on their own we would already have dispensed with the need for lawyers,” he said, adding that it was “the dialectic between the prosecution and the defence” which aimed, albeit imperfectly, to establish the truth in legal proceedings.
Raising a lack of clarity about the scale and extent of the legal representation to be made available to people brought before the proposed commission, Mr Smith said that even the ability to be questioned by his or her own lawyer could be as vital to an accused person’s interests during proceedings as the cross-examination of witnesses.
These rules, he stressed, were designed not only to protect individuals “but to ensure that the court or tribunal does not come to the wrong conclusion”.
Mr Smith said he believed the importance of protecting individuals in any search for truth could not be overstated, given the commission’s potential power to require admissions from witnesses that could destroy their reputations, or, in some cases at least, put their lives at risk.
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/local-national/speculation-over-police-involvement-in-killing-14202416.html
Wednesday, 25 February 2009
The murder of RUC Sergeant Joseph Campbell (right) on February 25 1977 sent shockwaves through the quiet rural community of Cushendall which had survived relatively unscathed through the Troubles.
The popular sergeant was hit by rifle fire as he locked the village police station for the evening. He received one wound to the head and died almost immediately, leaving behind a wife, Rosemary, and eight children.
Days before his death Sergeant Campbell’s behaviour had changed, it has been claimed, after he received a series of anonymous phone calls to his home.
Although the murder was initially attributed to the IRA, speculation about RUC involvement began and continued to circulate.
Special Branch Sergeant Charles McCormick was arrested and charged with the murder, but in 1982 was acquitted.
Interest in the case was sparked again 20 years later by a UTV Insight programme which claimed repeated warnings to senior officers that the Catholic officer’s life was in danger were ignored.
Sergeant Campbell’s family continued to allege police collusion in the murder and in 2002, after receiving information from the family, some journalists and British Irish Rights Watch, the Police Ombudsman’s Office began an investigation into circumstances surrounding his death.
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/opinion/letters/
Wednesday, 25 February 2009
The recent moves by the Ulster Unionist Party to forge formal links with the Conservatives shows the beginnings of normal issue-based politics in Northern Ireland.
The two emerging brands of unionism highlight the differences within unionism and show the UUP returning to its traditional roots as its ideals and policies converge with the Conservative and Unionist Party with which it has always had close relations.
There is now more than ever a need for a confident unionism that can keep its head high and be proud of its diversity and historic roots in promoting and fighting for the maintenance of a strong union with Great Britain.
With an increasing threat now also from Scottish nationalism, these links will strengthen unionism and give renewed impetus to ensure it remains a credible force throughout the UK. With the economy sliding into the most severe recession in 80 years the DUP, which promised to deliver in government, were caught in a stand off at Stormont.
This has resulted in paralysis government under mutual vetoes and side deals and shows DUP/Sinn Fein as inward looking and unable to make the big decisions necessary on the education system and the new stadium, leaving both in limbo at best and chaos at worst.
In line with the UUP's new objectives adopted in the recent rule changes, allied to the Conservatives and their policies of social justice, efficient public services, financial stability and a return to sensible economics, the UUP can offer a progressive, confident and outward-looking vision for unionism.
Edward Rea
Ulster Unionist Party
http://entertainment.timesonline.co.uk/tol/arts_and_entertainment/stage/theatre/article5774491.ece
From The TimesFebruary 23, 2009
From the fictional town of Ballybeg the Irish playwright has sent a series of dispatches from a world of dislocation and loss, but his works still nourish the soul
Brian Friel's Ballybeg - originally known in Gaelic as baile beag or “small town” - has known troubles galore. British sappers marched through in 1833, changing Irish place-names as they went and seeing an officer murdered in reprisal. Forty years later an English scientist came to measure peasant heads in order to bolster his theories about lesser breeds, and there was another killing, this time of a callous landowner. A century afterwards we find the great Ballybeg Hall in terminal disarray, a wandering shaman murdered in a local pub for failing to heal a crippled boy, a young man called Gar O'Donnell preparing to leave for a new life in America, and a blind woman given back her sight, only to lose it again.
Friel's imaginary Donegal town isn't a happy place, but it has given the Irish author of (respectively) Translations, The Home Place, Aristocrats, Faith Healer, Philadelphia, Here I Come! and Molly Sweeney plenty of rich, rewarding material and the rest of us unforgettable plays about dispossession, cultural change, exile, the importance of language and the meaning of history. And perhaps most memorably of all, Ballybeg gave birth to the Mundy sisters, all five of them, women who spent the 1930s precariously sustaining life, limb and the old values on the town's rural outskirts. That's to say, it engendered Dancing at Lughnasa, the play about to get its first major London staging since its British premiere at the National in 1990.
Back then Lughnasa won the best-play award at the Oliviers and at the Tonys in New York, bringing Friel the international renown and respect that he still enjoys. So is the play his masterpiece? That's for Anna Mackmin's revival at the Old Vic to answer. But if it fuses warmth, humour and melancholy as seamlessly as it should, it will make a worthy birthday gift for Friel, who has just turned 80, and justify his status as one of Ireland's seven Saoi of the Aosdána, meaning that he can wear the Golden Torc round his neck and is now officially what we fans know him to be: a Wise Man of the People of Art and, maybe, the greatest living English-language dramatist.
He certainly wasn't born with golden torcs or even silver spoons. He comes of peasant, Roman Catholic, Gaelic-speaking stock; two grandparents were illiterate; he grew up in a Derry street where he was scared to walk to the local shop because murderous Protestant thugs lurked there; he followed his father into schoolmastering, teaching maths in the Bogside; he joined the civil rights marches that escalated into Bloody Sunday and had to take cover when the Paras opened fire; he became a full-time writer and moved his family across the border into Donegal.
He's shy, withdrawn and no optimist: as he once said, “very jittery, vain, anxiety-ridden, worried and uneasy”. His days of giving interviews seem over, but he would presumably still call himself a nationalist, though one who feels that cultural rebirth must precede the political reunion of an Ireland that, thinking of Dublin and its “huckstering” politicians, he has called “a shabby imitation of a third-rate American state”.
Actually, Friel's work is seldom openly political. Even Freedom of the City, in which three harmless marchers are shot as they emerge from sanctuary in the Guildhall in Derry, is more about their troubled lives and the way they are mythologised after death by balladeers and other revisionists than about any atrocity. It's rather the same in Making History, which involves a real-life Earl of Tyrone who led a disastrous rebellion against Queen Elizabeth I, ended up a sad drunk in Rome, yet is recalled by his chronicler as “a God-like prince, glorious and pure”. As Friel sees it, “history” usually isn't truth - and “truth” often isn't truth either.
Certainly, each of the three characters in Faith Healer sees the title-character in different ways. Was he a genius, a charlatan or both? One magical night he cured ten people in an obscure Welsh village. One day he turned away as his mistress gave birth to a dead, ossified baby in a Scots field. It's a play that has seen James Mason, Donal McCann, Ken Stott and Ralph Fiennes take the main role, and it's important in two main ways. First, it's technically daring, since it consists of four monologues telling the same and not the same story. Second, as Friel concedes, it's a metaphor for the mysterious unpredictability of art, including his own: sometimes potent, sometimes useless, sometimes destructive.
That technical bravura permeates his work. Philadelphia, Here I Come! dramatises its aspiring émigré by asking one actor to play his energetic outer self, another the doubts, fears and angers festering inside. But, unlike his faith healer, Friel seldom fails. You can't easily categorise him - a friend once said that was like “shifting smoke with a pitchfork” - but for me he's the great bard of loss, dislocation, confusion and waste. Again and again he has asked a question that's Irish yet universal. Indeed, it's at the centre of The Home Place, which involves an Englishman who feels he belongs in Ballybeg, yet is forced by nationalist aggression back to Kent. Which is his home? And what is meant by “home”?
That question is as personal to Friel, the northerner at ease in neither British Ulster nor the Irish Republic, as to his creations. “Exile can be acquired by sitting in the same place for the rest of your life,” he once said. “Physical exile is not necessary.” So it's no wonder that his characters compulsively resist the punishing realities of Irish life. For a well-born loser in Aristocrats, the escape route is the imagination, which is why he feeds an American academic tall stories about Yeats, Chesterton, O'Casey and Hopkins's crazed doings in Ballybeg Hall. For blind Molly Sweeney it's an inner world more fulfilling than any she saw during her brief cure. For the “hedge-teacher” Hugh in Translations, it's alcohol, classical poetry and a rich Gaelic language “full of the mythologies of fantasy and hope and self-deception: our response to mud cabins and a diet of potatoes”.
Language matters hugely to Friel, which is one reason why, feeling that standard versions of Chekhov and Turgenev were “as English as Elgar”, he translated both into a distinctively Irish English. But he also finds 19th-century Russian characters congenial, ruefully recognising the way they cling to old certainties “while knowing in their hearts their society is in meltdown”. And Chekhov's people share the spiritual longing, the ache within, so evident in plays such as Friel's Wonderful Tennessee, whose unhappy Dubliners try and fail to visit an “island of otherness and mystery” near Ballybeg, yet are somehow refreshed by the attempt.
And refreshed is what Friel's work makes you feel. Yes, he has described writing plays as “delving into a corner of yourself that's dark and uneasy and articulating the confusions” and exploring Irish minds “which have many windows and the blinds are often down”. But his friend Seamus Heaney is right to say that the dramatist still leaves you renewed, elated, “with a sense of rightness even though things have manifestly gone wrong for the people onstage”. Heaney is, of course, a Nobel laureate. Isn't it time Friel was too?
Dancing at Lughnasa is in preview at the Old Vic, London SE1 (0870 0606628; www.oldvictheatre.com), from Thurs, and runs from March 5 to May 9
STAGE DIRECTIONS: THE LIFE OF BRIAN
1929 Born in Omagh, son of Patrick Friel, who moved family to Derry, where he was a primary school teacher.
1954 Marries Anne Morrison: they have four daughters and one son.
1959 Begins writing short stories regularly for The New Yorker, which allows him to take up writing as a career. He has published two collections of short stories.
1966 Moves his family from Derry to Donegal in the Irish Republic.
1964 Philadelphia, Here I Come! is performed in Dublin, London and New York.
1973 Premiere of Freedom of the City, his take on the Troubles.
1979 Faith Healer premiere
1980 Translations is first presented by Field Day, a Northern Irish touring company founded by Friel and the actor Stephen Rea, at the Guildhall, Derry.
1981 The first of his translations of Russian authors, Chekhov's Three Sisters, is performed.
1987 to 1989 Appointed to the Irish Senate in Dublin.
1990 Dancing at Lughnasa performed in Dublin, and goes on to pick up top awards in London and New York. In 1998 made into a film starring Meryl Streep.
2005 The Home Place, his most recent play, performed in Dublin and London.
2006 Awarded the Golden Torc by the President of Ireland, Mary McAleese.
2008 Queens University, Belfast, announces plans to build a Brian Friel Theatre and Centre for Theatrical Research.
http://www.metro.co.uk/metrolife/films/
DVD Of The Week: Hunger, Pathé Distribution, 15, £19.99
by SIOBHAN MURPHY - Monday, February 23, 2009
Rating: 5 STARS
Hunger Turner Prize-winning artist Steve McQueen's first feature film is an extraordinary piece of work.
Truly harrowing, it nonetheless rewards repeated viewing for McQueen's exquisite framing of detail and beautifully crafted juxtapositions.
The 1981 Maze prison hunger strike led by Bobby Sands forms the stark focus of this examination of the extremes of bodily suffering, presented as a kind of triptych.
We start with a Maze prison officer (Stuart Graham) preparing for work and are gradually led into a visceral relationship with the Irish republican prisoners observing the 'dirty' and 'blanket' protests, who are brutalised both by their own actions and by the guards.
An almost total absence of dialogue means sound, and how it's used as a weapon, becomes all important.
It also means the film's centrepiece – a 22-minute static conversation between a silhouetted Sands (Michael Fassbender) and Father Moran (Liam Cunningham), filmed in an unbroken sequence – has even more force, as the pair thrust and parry through a debate about the morality of the hunger strike.
The final uncompromising segment shows Sands in his last days, as his body deteriorates (the emaciated state Fassbender achieved for this role is truly shocking) – and the tenderness with which he is administered to, after such brutality, is almost unbearable.
McQueen's sense of how to balance delicacy and violence is breathtaking; the performances he coaxes are deeply moving. This is innovative, involving and highly affecting film-making.
Extras: Making-of featurette, interviews with McQueen, Fassbender and producers.
http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/breaking/2009/0225/breaking60.htm
RONAN McGREEVY
Wed, Feb 25, 2009
Protesters have demonstrated outside the Department of Finance against U2’s decision to move their tax affairs to the Netherlands to avoid paying tax on their royalties in Ireland.
The protest was organised by the Debt and Development Coalition Ireland (DDCI) which campaigns on issues related to the developing world. The coalition contains such organisations as Concern Worldwide, Trócaire, Oxfam and various Catholic missionary orders.
U2 moved their publishing arm to the Netherlands in 2006 after the Government capped tax-free earnings for artists at €250,000. Previously, U2 had been one of the biggest beneficiaries of Ireland's tax-free status for artist royalties.
The coalition met Minister for Finance Brian Lenihan who pointed out that the Government had abolished the Cinderella rule where people could say they had not spent a day in Ireland if they left by midnight.
“We have tax treaties with other countries that regulate where you pay tax. There is a problem with smaller countries that have to set up deliberate tax havens. We are raising that at EU level,” the Minister said though he did not address the specific issue of U2’s tax affairs. The band are resident in Ireland for tax purposes.
Accounts for 2007 for U2 Ltd show the band paid out more than €21 million in wages in 2007 in a relatively quiet year where they were not touring or releasing new material.
Bono impersonator Paul O’Toole reworked the lyrics of I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking Forto mock the band’s decision. “I know avoiding tax ain’t fair/it’s just because I’m a millionaire, I don’t need to pay like you, no, I won’t pay like you/because I still haven’t learned about democracy.”
Mr O’Toole said: “Their music does not bother me. It is their policy of avoiding tax that bothers me. Bono talks about dead kids, but he won’t pay a penny towards it.”
Mr O’Toole posed with a mock-up of a donation to the world's poor in one hand and a large sack of unpaid tax in the other.
The DDCI is following it up with the launch of an “international song contest” inviting re-worded versions of U2 classics to highlight the band’s stance on tax.
It is timed to coincide with the release of U2's new album No Line on the Horizon which goes on sale at midnight on Friday.
DDCI co-ordinator Nessa ní Chasaíde said the decision to holding the protest outside the department of Finance was to highlight the fact that U2’s tax avoidance measures deprives the Irish exchequer of taxation revenue that could be spent on development aid.
“Bono has championed the call for increases in aid to impoverished countries, yet in his personal life he is engaged in tax avoidance issues and it is tax avoidance that is undermining the possibility of developing countries fighting their way out of poverty,” she said.
“The practice of being able to move your finances around easily and without high levels of transparency is extremely problematic for developing countries. The kind of practice that U2 is engaging in is part of that problem.”
Nobody from U2 was available for comment, but the band will defend their tax measures in an extensive interview to be published in this newspaper on Friday.
© 2009 irishtimes.com